Island Burger and Shake Restaurant Review – Fort Pierce, FL

Located near the Fort Pierce Jetty, where Taco Dive used to be, Island Burger and Shake brings to life a simple yet powerful idea: creating a place where everyone feels at home. The recently opened restaurant is quickly making a name for itself, thanks to its commitment to fresh ingredients, flavorful dishes, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, Island Burger and Shake invites you to indulge in great food in an environment that celebrates good company and great times.


Created by seasoned restaurateur Taylor Shull, he brings fresh, from-scratch food and a laid-back vibe to Fort Pierce. After the success of his first local restaurant, Island Pig & Fish (Read Review), Taylor decided to introduce this winning concept to the area. With a background as COO of RW Restaurant Group in Washington, DC, he saw the opportunity to offer a unique culinary experience. Now with a third venture, Hutchinson Island Bar & Grill, recently opened (stay tuned for a review), Taylor continues to build spaces where quality, flavor, and community thrive.
A VERY LIMITED QUANTITY Gift Card deal is available at the bottom of this article. They usually sell out within hours of when this article is published, so don’t wait to purchase quickly if you want one!
The Wagyu Burger
The Wagyu Burger is an absolute must-try for any burger lover. Made with delicious Wagyu beef, this burger offers a melt-in-your-mouth experience. The beef is tender and juicy, perfectly complemented by fresh toppings and a soft, toasted bun. The flavor profile is rich and satisfying, without being overwhelming. It’s served with the chef’s special sauce, topped off with a pickle, and comes with a side of spicy and truffle mayo for an added kick.
The Big Daddy Burger
If you’re in the mood for something hearty, the Big Daddy Burger is sure to satisfy your cravings. This towering burger features a perfectly seasoned patties, topped with melted cheese, crispy bacon, and fresh veggies, all piled high between a sturdy bun that holds it all together. The combination of textures and flavors—crispy, juicy, fresh, and savory—creates a harmonious bite every time. Like the Wagyu, it’s served with the chef’s special sauce, topped with a pickle, and comes with a side of spicy and truffle mayo. This is a burger lover’s absolute dream!

Kitchen Sink Fries
As the name suggests, the Kitchen Sink Fries are loaded with every topping you can imagine: gooey cheese, bacon, green onions, and a generous drizzle of savory chef’s special sauce. Each fry is crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, and is best enjoyed alongside the burger. They’re ideal for sharing (or not!), and with every bite, you’ll find yourself coming back for more.
Milkshakes
To wrap up the meal, the milkshakes are an essential treat! We tried the Vanilla Bean milkshake and the monthly special, Mint Chocolate Chip shake. The Vanilla Bean shake is pure nostalgia—rich, creamy, and packed with real vanilla flavor, topped off with a cherry. The Mint Chocolate Chip shake offers a refreshing twist, with a cool minty flavor and chunks of chocolate that make each sip a delight. You can’t go wrong with a shake here for dessert.
Island Burger and Shake is more than just a place to grab a meal—it’s a spot that brings people together. Whether you’re stopping by for a casual burger with friends after a day at the beach, looking to connect with family over dinner, or just wanting to enjoy a perfectly crafted milkshake after a day in the sun, this new restaurant in Fort Pierce is a must-visit.
Be sure to follow them on Instagram and Facebook to stay updated on specials and new menu offerings!
Island Burger and Shake
Address: 2025 Seaway Dr, Fort Pierce, FL 34949
Phone: (772) 242-8316
https://islandburgerandshake.com/

Get a $20 Gift Card for ONLY $10 at Island Burger and Shake
Gift Cards will be mailed to you via USPS regular mail delivery. Purchase is limited to one per person, per transaction.
Keywords: Island Burger and Shake, Fort Pierce restaurants, Wagyu Burger, Big Daddy Burger, Kitchen Sink Fries, Vanilla Bean milkshake, Mint Chocolate Chip shake, Fort Pierce burger spot, Taylor Shull restaurant, Fresh ingredients, Local Fort Pierce dining, Beachside dining Fort Pierce, Best burgers in Fort Pierce, New Fort Pierce restaurant, Burgers and milkshakes, This article is a paid advertisement for the restaurant featured in this blog post. All opinions expressed in this post are based on our own experience with the business and its products, Best new restaurant near the Fort Pierce Jetty, Where to find the best Wagyu Burger in Fort Pierce, Family-friendly dining in Fort Pierce, Island Burger and Shake’s fresh ingredient philosophy, Top spots for burgers and milkshakes in Fort Pierce, Hearty Big Daddy Burger with crispy bacon and cheese, Loaded Kitchen Sink Fries with cheese, bacon, and chef’s sauce, Milkshakes at Island Burger and Shake: Vanilla Bean and Mint Chocolate Chip, Taylor Shull’s latest restaurant in Fort Pierce, Perfect spot for burgers and shakes after a day at the beach, Fort Pierce restaurants offering fresh, from-scratch food, Best casual dining experience in Fort Pierce, Island Burger and Shake’s community-focused dining, Gourmet burgers and unique milkshakes near Fort Pierce Jetty, Island-inspired burgers and fries with a chef’s touch.