Italian Princess Bakery & Deli Review – Palm Bay, FL

As a New Jersey native, I’m always on the hunt for a good Italian bakery like the ones I grew up with. When I heard about Italian Princess Bakery & Deli, I had to check it out.

Located on Malabar Rd, Italian Princess Bakery & Deli is the creation of husband-and-wife duo Brenton and Rose. After meeting in 2010 and bonding over their Italian roots and shared love for cooking and baking, they left their corporate retail careers to pursue their dream. In 2024, that dream came to life with a cozy bakery that blends Southern Italian traditions with a touch of New York flair. From hand-rolled NY-style bagels to authentic Italian dishes and pastries, Italian Princess offers Palm Bay a delicious taste of Italy.

Italian Princess Bakery & Deli catches your eye with its playful sign in the colors of the Italian flag, topped with a crown over the “P” in Princess.

Inside, the space is bright and full of girlish charm with a wafting aroma of delicious baked goods. In the back corner, a white Cinderella-style carriage with two benches for seating adds a touch of fairytale whimsy. A chandelier overhead brings sparkle, while glass display counters showcase cookies and pastries, and signs feature the daily selections.

I kicked off my lunch with the “Naples” sandwich, a local favorite. Served on house-made hero bread with mortadella, pepperoni, and salami, it strikes the perfect balance of smoky, spicy, and sweet. Fresh mozzarella adds creaminess, while romaine, tomato, and red onion provide refreshing crunch. On the side, a comforting cup of Pasta Fagioli, made with cannelloni beans, puréed vegetables, and elbow pasta, was warm and hearty with a bit of a kick—perfect for dipping bread.

After my savory course, I turned my attention to dessert—because no visit to an Italian bakery is complete without something sweet.

First up was the Raspberry Cake, a moist chocolate base layered with raspberry frosting and a bright, tangy raspberry compote. The rich cake paired with light raspberry frosting and tangy compote offered a perfect balance of sweetness and depth. The raspberry compote added a pop of flavor that cut through the richness beautifully—indulgent, but not overwhelming. The seasonal St. Joseph’s Zeppole was equally impressive. The dough had delicate lemon notes, and inside, a traditional cannoli filling with chocolate chips. Topped with more filling and a festive green cherry, it was soft, creamy, and just sweet enough—a comforting yet elevated take on a classic.

The cookie selection reminded me of the ones I grew up enjoying—classic, traditional, and colorful. The Italian leaf cookies came in pistachio and strawberry. A smooth chocolate filling held the layers together, adding just the right amount of richness. The pistachio had a subtle, nutty warmth, while the strawberry offered a light, fruity sweetness. Full of nostalgic charm, they were every bit as satisfying as they looked. The Butter Almond Sandwiches with raspberry filling are a personal favorite, and Italian Princess Bakery’s are the best I’ve had. Rich, buttery, and melt-in-your-mouth, the almond flavor adds warmth while the raspberry balances the richness, making for an irresistible combination. Lastly, I tried the pizzelles—thin and crisp with a soft center. Available with powdered sugar or a drizzle of chocolate, each one carried that classic vanilla flavor that feels instantly familiar.

Whether you’re craving a hearty sandwich, a nostalgic pastry, or a sweet post-dinner treat, Italian Princess Bakery & Deli offers it all with quick, friendly service. Brenton and Rose have created a space that captures the warmth of American-Italian charm, blending tradition with a welcoming atmosphere.

ITALIAN PRINCESS BAKERY & DELI
Address: 600 Malabar Rd, Palm Bay, FL 32907
Phone: (321) 372-1227
https://www.italianprincesspb.com/

Keywords: Italian bakery Palm Bay, Italian Princess Bakery & Deli, best Italian bakery in Palm Bay, Palm Bay deli and bakery, New York style bagels Palm Bay, authentic Italian pastries Florida, Italian sandwiches Palm Bay, Pasta Fagioli Palm Bay, St. Joseph’s Zeppole bakery, homemade hero sandwiches Florida, raspberry cake Italian bakery, almond raspberry cookies bakery, Italian leaf cookies Palm Bay, Italian desserts Palm Bay FL, traditional Italian cookies Florida, best cannoli Palm Bay, Southern Italian bakery Florida, where to find pizzelles Palm Bay, Italian bakery with sandwiches Florida, cozy Italian bakery experience, Italian bakery near me Palm Bay, Brenton and Rose bakery owners, homemade Italian food Palm Bay, family-owned bakery Palm Bay FL, Italian sweets and pastries Florida, Italian deli sandwiches near me, fresh baked goods Palm Bay FL, cannoli filled zeppole Florida, traditional Italian desserts Palm Bay, unique bakeries in Palm Bay, best raspberry cake Florida bakery, authentic Italian deli Florida, Italian-American bakery Florida, nostalgic Italian cookies bakery, cozy cafes in Palm Bay FL, Italian bakery chocolate pizzelles, gourmet Italian pastries Palm Bay, Italian bagels and sandwiches Florida, hidden bakery gems Palm Bay, Italian baking traditions Florida