fbpx
Restaurant ReviewPSL | Jensen Beach | Stuart

Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza Restaurant Review – Stuart, Florida

Craving a slice of Chicago? Look no further than Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza in Downtown Stuart, where thin-crust dreams come true! Known for serving up authentic Chicago-style pizza, Pusateri’s is a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking both traditional favorites and innovative twists.

island-pig-and-fish-wide
green-marlin-wide
riverside-banner
tipsy-gypsy-wide
ocean-grill-wide
tccsf-wide
BCBC-wide-72ppi
armanis-banner
rosie-malloys-wide
chive-wide
american-icon-wide-2
celebration-grove-wide
sacred-grounds-wide
Counter-Culture-Wide
island-burger-and-shake-wide
Front entrance of Pusateri's Chicago Pizza place located in Stuart, Florida

Pusateri’s is owned by Miami native Tom Bean, a longtime resident of Sewall’s Point and Sailfish Point, as well as a private jet pilot and yachtsman. Determined to preserve a local treasure, Bean purchased the restaurant in 2021 after it nearly closed during the coronavirus pandemic.

Dine al fresco on the patio out back at Pusateri's Chicago Pizza place located in Stuart, Florida

What makes Pusateri’s truly stand out is their dedication to keeping the spirit of classic Chicago-style thin crust pizza alive—just as it was when they first opened their doors 22 years ago. Their menu is a love letter to the bold, unmistakable flavors that made Chicago pizza famous. From their signature square-cut, pub-style pies to the rich, savory toppings, each bite is a nostalgic nod to tradition, bringing that authentic Chicago experience right to Stuart.

Here’s a breakdown of some standout dishes you need to try:

Hot Honey Pepperoni Thin Crust Pizza as prepared by Pusateri's Chicago Pizza place located in Stuart, Florida

Regular Pepperoni Hot Pizza: If you’re a pepperoni purist, your taste buds will be in heaven. Pusateri’s regular pepperoni hot pizza is a masterpiece of bold flavors. The balance between the savory pepperoni and a drizzle of hot honey creates a sweet-heat combo that sets this pizza apart. It’s the kind of slice that keeps you coming back for more, with just enough spice to warm your taste buds without overwhelming them. This one’s a fan favorite, as well as my personal favorite!

celebration-grove-wide
green-marlin-wide
tccsf-wide
island-pig-and-fish-wide
Counter-Culture-Wide
tipsy-gypsy-wide
BCBC-wide-72ppi
american-icon-wide-2
riverside-banner
rosie-malloys-wide
island-burger-and-shake-wide
armanis-banner
chive-wide
sacred-grounds-wide
ocean-grill-wide
The Very Veggie with a Gluten-Free crust pizza as prepared by Pusateri's Chicago Pizza place located in Stuart, Florida

Gluten-Free Very Veggie Pizza: Now who says healthy can’t be delicious? Pusateri’s Gluten-Free Very Veggie Pizza is proof that you don’t have to sacrifice flavor for a healthier option. Piled high with fresh vegetables and served on a perfectly crispy gluten-free crust, this pizza is a crowd-pleaser for everyone—whether you have dietary restrictions or you’re just looking to mix it up. It’s vibrant, flavorful, and packed with the goodness of garden-fresh ingredients, making it a guilt-free indulgence.

Pusateri's Bread as prepared by Pusateri's Chicago Pizza place located in Stuart, Florida

Pusateri’s Bread: No pizza experience is complete without a side of bread, and Pusateri’s Bread is a showstopper all on its own. Don’t be fooled by its simple appearance—this bread packs a punch. The golden, crispy exterior gives way to a fluffy interior with a surprise kick of spice. Perfect for dipping or enjoying on its own, Pusateri’s Bread is the kind of side that earns a spot on the table every time.

The Chi-Town Combo Sandwich as prepared by Pusateri's Chicago Pizza place located in Stuart, Florida

Chi-Town Combo: The Chi-Town Combo is a meat lover’s dream. This hearty dish features Pusateri’s famous sausage flat-style topped with hot Italian roast beef. It comes one way—with just a dash of red sauce and au jus drippings from the seasoned beef—and that’s all it needs to satisfy even the biggest appetite. It’s bold, flavorful, and unapologetically indulgent.

rosie-malloys-wide
american-icon-wide-2
tccsf-wide
island-pig-and-fish-wide
chive-wide
island-burger-and-shake-wide
tipsy-gypsy-wide
BCBC-wide-72ppi
celebration-grove-wide
ocean-grill-wide
green-marlin-wide
armanis-banner
Counter-Culture-Wide
sacred-grounds-wide
riverside-banner
A cannoli drizzled with chocolate sauce as prepared by Pusateri's Chicago Pizza place located in Stuart, Florida

Cannolis: Pusateri’s cannolis are the perfect way to wrap up your meal. These locally made treats are baked fresh daily and offer a creamy, sweet filling encased in a crisp shell. But don’t wait too long—they’re available on a first-come, first-served basis, making them a coveted delight for those lucky enough to snag one!

At Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza, the flavors are big, and the portions are hearty. Whether you’re grabbing a slice to go or settling in for a cozy dine-in experience, you’ll be treated to top-notch service and a menu that caters to many pizza preferences. From classic pepperoni to gluten-free veggie options and everything in between, Pusateri’s brings the taste of Chicago to Stuart with pride.

green-marlin-wide
BCBC-wide-72ppi
sacred-grounds-wide
ocean-grill-wide
tccsf-wide
celebration-grove-wide
tipsy-gypsy-wide
american-icon-wide-2
Counter-Culture-Wide
chive-wide
armanis-banner
island-burger-and-shake-wide
riverside-banner
island-pig-and-fish-wide
rosie-malloys-wide

Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza
Address221 SE Ocean Blvd, Stuart, FL 34994
Phone: (772) 288-9810
https://pusaterispizza.com/

Keywords: Chicago-style pizza, Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza, Thin-crust pizza, Authentic Chicago pizza, Pizza in Downtown Stuart, Gluten-free pizza options, Pepperoni pizza, Chicago pizza flavors, Stuart pizza restaurants, Best pizza in Stuart, Authentic Chicago-style thin-crust pizza in Stuart, Where to find Chicago pizza in Downtown Stuart, Gluten-free veggie pizza options at Pusateri’s, Best pizza with hot honey and pepperoni in Stuart, Top Chicago-style pizza restaurant in Stuart, FL, Family-friendly pizza spots in Downtown Stuart, Bold flavors of Chicago-style pizza in Florida, Pusateri’s gluten-free pizza for dietary restrictions, Italian-American classics like cannolis in Stuart, Best pizza and bread sides in Downtown Stuart, Pusateri’s thin-crust pizza in Stuart, Classic Chicago pizza in Florida, Best gluten-free pizza in Stuart, Chicago-style pepperoni pizza with hot honey, Downtown Stuart pizza dining, Local pizza restaurant with authentic Chicago flavors, Sausage and Italian roast beef pizza combo, Freshly made cannolis in Stuart, Chicago pub-style pizza near me, Hearty pizza portions in Downtown Stuart.

armanis-banner
BCBC-wide-72ppi
celebration-grove-wide
rosie-malloys-wide
chive-wide
ocean-grill-wide
tipsy-gypsy-wide
island-pig-and-fish-wide
green-marlin-wide
tccsf-wide
american-icon-wide-2
island-burger-and-shake-wide
riverside-banner
sacred-grounds-wide
Counter-Culture-Wide

Sabrina Webb

Blending a passion for storytelling with a love of all things delicious, Sabrina brings years of experience in journalism and marketing to Treasure Coast Foodies. As a seasoned writer, Sabrina crafts vivid and compelling articles that showcase the best flavors and hidden gems of the local culinary scene. With a proven track record in media and professional communication, Sabrina is dedicated to bringing the Treasure Coast’s food stories to life—one bite at a time.

Related Articles

One Comment

Back to top button