Restaurant ReviewVero Beach

Giorgio’s New York Pizzeria Restaurant Review – Vero Beach, Fl

Nestled in the heart of Vero Beach, Giorgio’s New York Pizzeria stands as a testament to culinary legacy and reinvention. For 25 years, the pizzeria was the brainchild of George, a charismatic and eccentric figure who infused every pizza slice with a dash of his vibrant personality. His wild stories and dedication to authentic New York-style pizza made Giorgio’s a beloved spot among locals and visitors alike.

rosie-malloys-wide
ocean-grill-wide
american-icon-wide-2
tequila-azteca
Counter-Culture-Wide
Quik-Snak
VIRC-Wide
padel-grille
taj-mahal
chive-wide
mai-thai
dinner-revo
Daddys-Donuts
riverside-banner
island-pig-and-fish-wide
BCBC-wide-72ppi
celebration-grove-wide
green-marlin-wide
tipsy-gypsy-wide
The front out side of Giorgio's New York Pizzeria located in Vero Beach Florida

However, the winds of change blew in when Rick and Bridget arrived in Vero Beach 2 1/2 years ago, seeking a new chapter in their lives as empty nesters. Drawn by the serene charm of the area, they stumbled upon Giorgio’s, where they discovered not just exceptional pizza, but also a potential opportunity for a fresh start. After several visits and heartfelt conversations with George, the couple decided to take the plunge and purchased the pizzeria, marking their first foray into the restaurant business. With a deep respect for Giorgio’s heritage, Rick and Bridget are now on a journey to uphold its traditions while injecting their own passion and innovation into every cheesy, doughy delight served at Giorgio’s New York Pizzeria.

VERY LIMITED QUANTITY Gift Card deal is available at the end of this article. They usually sell out within hours of when this article has been published, so don’t wait to purchase quickly if you want one!

Now let’s dive right in and see what this place has to offer and what I had to eat!

Meatball Parmigiana Sub sandwich as prepared by Giorgio's New York Pizzeria located in Vero Beach Florida

I’m always on the lookout for a fantastic meatball sandwich, and Giorgio’s Homemade Meatball Parmigiana Sub absolutely delivers! Packed with homemade meatballs, a generous helping of marinara sauce, and a blend of mozzarella & provolone cheeses, all sandwiched between a perfectly toasted bun, this sandwich is absolutely delicious. The meatballs are tender and flavorful, the sauce is rich and savory, and the cheese adds that perfect gooey finish. I’m already counting the days until I can enjoy this again!

Lasagna dinner which includes a house salad and garlic knots as prepared by Giorgio's New York Pizzeria located in Vero Beach Florida

The next dish I couldn’t resist trying is their Lasagna, and let me tell you, it was an excellent choice! The portion was more than generous, topped with their house-made marinara and a flavorful cheese blend, and baked to perfection. Served alongside a fresh house salad and garlic knots, it made for a complete and satisfying meal. The pasta sheets were al dente and easy to cut through with just a fork, the sauce was rich and savory, and the cheese blend created the perfect cheesy pull with each bite!

dinner-revo
chive-wide
tequila-azteca
mai-thai
rosie-malloys-wide
BCBC-wide-72ppi
Counter-Culture-Wide
padel-grille
Quik-Snak
riverside-banner
Daddys-Donuts
taj-mahal
green-marlin-wide
ocean-grill-wide
tipsy-gypsy-wide
american-icon-wide-2
island-pig-and-fish-wide
celebration-grove-wide
VIRC-Wide
A white pizza pie as prepared by Giorgio's New York Pizzeria located in Vero Beach Florida

The first pizza I ordered was the N.Y. White Pizza. I got the 16″, which is considered their “medium” compared to other pizza places where a 16″ is typically a large. Made with fresh dough crafted in-house daily and hand-tossed to just the right thickness, is topped with olive oil, garlic, fresh basil, Italian spices, Parmesan, mozzarella, Asiago cheese, and finished with dollops of fresh ricotta cheese. The garlic and ricotta were definitely the predominant flavors on this pie, and for garlic lovers, this pizza is a must-try. I can’t wait to stop by and order it again soon!

A margarita style pizza pie as prepared by Giorgio's New York Pizzeria located in Vero Beach Florida

Next up was the Margherita Pizza, a sizable 20″ pie that’s considered their large. Made with fresh dough crafted in-house daily and hand-tossed to just the right thickness., it boasts a delicious combination of fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh tomatoes, basil, grated cheese blend, and olive oil. As a fan of saucy pizzas, I was pleased with the generous amount of sauce they used. Margherita pizzas are celebrated for their simplicity, and this one certainly exceeded my expectations.

Indulging my sweet tooth, I couldn’t resist trying two of their suggested desserts—the Limoncello Cake and the Chocolate Fudge Cake. Both were delightfully moist and incredibly delicious, but if I had to pick a favorite, it would definitely be the rich and decadent Chocolate Fudge Cake.

american-icon-wide-2
Counter-Culture-Wide
padel-grille
tequila-azteca
tipsy-gypsy-wide
BCBC-wide-72ppi
green-marlin-wide
Daddys-Donuts
mai-thai
VIRC-Wide
celebration-grove-wide
Quik-Snak
taj-mahal
riverside-banner
chive-wide
dinner-revo
island-pig-and-fish-wide
rosie-malloys-wide
ocean-grill-wide

Giorgio’s New York Pizzeria
Address: 955 17th St, Vero Beach, FL 32960
Phone: (772) 778-3800
https://www.giorgiospizza.us/

Did you miss out on our Gift Card deal? It sold out in only 4 hours!!! Our email subscribers and mobile app users are the first to know about these deals, so be sure to subscribe and download and install our free mobile app so you don’t miss out next time!

Quik-Snak
green-marlin-wide
BCBC-wide-72ppi
Daddys-Donuts
Counter-Culture-Wide
dinner-revo
ocean-grill-wide
riverside-banner
tequila-azteca
american-icon-wide-2
padel-grille
rosie-malloys-wide
celebration-grove-wide
mai-thai
taj-mahal
chive-wide
island-pig-and-fish-wide
VIRC-Wide
tipsy-gypsy-wide

keywords: Giorgio’s New York Pizza, Vero Beach pizza restaurant, Italian cuisine Vero Beach, Authentic New York-style pizza, Hand-tossed pizza crust, Homemade meatball sub, Lasagna with marinara sauce, N.Y. White Pizza ingredients, Margherita pizza flavors, Lemonchello Cake dessert, Chocolate Fudge Cake indulgence, Fresh ingredients pizza, Italian spices and herbs, Mozzarella and Parmesan cheese blend, Ricotta cheese dollops, Family-owned pizzeria, Best pizza place in Vero Beach, Casual dining experience, Delicious Italian dishes, Local pizza favorites, Vero Beach pizza, Pizza delivery Vero Beach FL, Best pizza in Vero Beach, Pizza restaurants Vero Beach, Italian pizza Vero Beach, Pizza places near me Vero Beach FL, Thin crust pizza Vero Beach, Wood-fired pizza Vero Beach, Gluten-free pizza Vero Beach, Gourmet pizza Vero Beach, Family-friendly pizza Vero Beach, Authentic New York-style pizza Vero Beach, Specialty pizza Vero Beach, Pizza catering Vero Beach FL, Delicious pizza Vero Beach, Local pizza Vero Beach, Takeout pizza Vero Beach, Neapolitan pizza Vero Beach, Artisanal pizza Vero Beach, Pizza deals Vero Beach FL. This article is a paid advertisement for the restaurant featured in this blog post. All opinions expressed in this post are based on our own experience with the business and its products.

BCBC-wide-72ppi
Counter-Culture-Wide
padel-grille
ocean-grill-wide
tipsy-gypsy-wide
tequila-azteca
VIRC-Wide
mai-thai
taj-mahal
green-marlin-wide
chive-wide
celebration-grove-wide
Quik-Snak
Daddys-Donuts
rosie-malloys-wide
dinner-revo
riverside-banner
american-icon-wide-2
island-pig-and-fish-wide

Thomas Miller

Thomas Miller, known as “The Treasure Coast Foodie,” is a celebrated food blogger, producer, and culinary storyteller. He is the owner and Editor in Chief of The Treasure Coast Foodie Blog and the host and producer of Holy Grail Eats, where he spotlights one-of-a-kind restaurants and their exceptional “Holy Grail” dishes. With over a decade of experience and more than 300 restaurant reviews, Thomas’s signature food photography and storytelling captivate tens of thousands of followers each month. As the Official Foodie Insider for Visit Indian River County, he champions the local dining scene and inspires a loyal community of over 125,000 food lovers across the Treasure Coast. His expertise has been featured in Coastal Drive Magazine, and as a Google Maps Level 8 Local Guide, Thomas has shared over 4,500 photos, viewed more than 110 million times. His signature Foodie dining events rank among the Treasure Coast’s premier culinary experiences.

Related Articles

Back to top button