Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza Restaurant Review – Stuart, FL

If you’re seeking a delicious escape to the heart of Chicago’s culinary legacy without leaving Stuart, Florida, Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza is where you’ll want to be. Under the stewardship of Tom Bean, a Miami native with deep roots in Sewall’s Point and Sailfish Point, this restaurant has become a beacon of authentic Windy City flavor in the Sunshine State. In a story that mirrors resilience and passion, Bean, a commercial jet pilot and seasoned yachtsman, took the reins of Pusateri’s in 2021, rescuing it from the brink of closure during the tumultuous times of the pandemic.

What sets Pusateri’s apart is its unwavering commitment to preserving the original essence of Chicago-style thin crust pizza, just as it was when the doors first opened 18 years ago. The menu remains a faithful homage to the flavors and traditions that have made Chicago pizza renowned worldwide. Here, you’ll find the hallmark square-cut, pub-style pizzas that have become synonymous with the Windy City and its bustling suburbs.

With each bite, you’ll experience a slice of history and tradition, crafted with care and expertise that spans generations. Pusateri’s isn’t just a place to enjoy a meal; it’s a journey through the culinary landscape of Chicago, right here in the vibrant coastal town of Stuart, Florida.

A VERY LIMITED QUANTITY gift card deal is available at the end of this article. They usually sell out within hours of when this article has been published, so don’t wait to purchase quickly if you want one!

Let’s dive into the tantalizing flavors and unique experiences that await you at Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza.

The Chicago-Style Dog is a symphony of flavors and textures on a steamed poppy seed bun. Customizable with yellow mustard, “Bright green relish,” chopped onion, tomato wedges, a dill pickle spear, sport peppers, and celery salt, this iconic dish delights with its smoky hot dog, crunchy relish, tangy pickle, and soft bun. It’s a taste of Chicago’s culinary heritage that promises to satisfy cravings for classic comfort food with each flavorful bite.

Next up, I tried their Italian Beef Sandwich, a straightforward yet delicious rendition of this Windy City favorite. Featuring thinly sliced hot Italian roast beef on toasted bread, you have the option to dip it in seasoned au jus for added flavor. I opted to include the hot Gardiner for a bit of spice, which complemented the flavorful and tender roast beef perfectly. Overall, it’s a satisfying and classic dish that hits the spot.

Moving on to the delightful Baked Ziti, I was treated to a comforting Italian classic that exceeded expectations. This dish features penne pasta with creamy ricotta cheese and marinara sauce, all baked to perfection under a blanket of melted mozzarella. The combination of ricotta and marinara created a lusciously creamy sauce that coated every bite of the perfectly cooked al dente pasta. The golden-brown layer of mozzarella added a delightful cheesy bite to each forkful, making it one of my favorites during this review.

Continuing my dining experience, I tried their Chicken Parmigiana, a classic Italian favorite. A hearty portion of breaded chicken breast, fried to a golden brown, was served on a bed of spaghetti and baked with mozzarella cheese. The chicken retained its crispy texture, especially around the edges, and the seasoned coating added a rich flavor to each bite. Paired with the savory marinara sauce and melted mozzarella, it was a satisfying and comforting dish that hit the spot.

The standout dish at Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza was definitely the Large Chicago Fire pizza, a spicy masterpiece designed for heat lovers. Topped with meatballs, thin-sliced Italian roast beef, hot Gardiner, and a sport pepper garnish on a satisfyingly chewy, yet thin crust, this 16″ pizza packs a fiery punch that’s not for the faint of heart. The spicy kick from the hot toppings was exhilarating, and despite its heat, the flavors remained harmonious and balanced. I enjoyed it so much that I couldn’t resist grabbing a few more bites on the drive home, making it a must-try for anyone seeking a flavorful and fiery pizza experience.

Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza
Address: 221 SE Ocean Blvd, Stuart, FL 34994
Phone: (772) 288-9810
https://pusaterispizza.com/

Get a $25 Gift Card for ONLY $15 at Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza

Gift Cards will be mailed to you via USPS regular mail delivery.  Purchase is limited to one per person, per transaction.

$15.00

Shop now

Keywords: Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza, Stuart, Florida, Restaurant review, Tom Bean, Chicago-style thin crust pizza, Square-cut pizza, Pub-style pizza, Authentic Chicago flavors, Italian Beef Sandwich, Baked Ziti, Chicken Parmigiana, Chicago Fire pizza, Spicy pizza, Meatballs, Italian roast beef, Hot Gardiner, Sport pepper, Thin crust pizza, Spicy food, Flavorful dishes, Stuart restaurants, Dining in Stuart FL, Best restaurants Stuart, Stuart FL food scene, Top-rated eateries Stuart, Seafood restaurants Stuart, Fine dining Stuart FL, Casual dining Stuart, Waterfront dining Stuart, Family-friendly restaurants Stuart, Breakfast spots Stuart, Lunch options Stuart FL, Dinner places Stuart, Outdoor dining Stuart FL, Pet-friendly restaurants Stuart, Local cuisine Stuart FL, Vegan-friendly restaurants Stuart, Gluten-free dining Stuart, Farm-to-table restaurants Stuart FL, Happy hour specials Stuart. This article is a paid advertisement for the restaurant featured in this blog post. All opinions expressed in this post are based on our own experience with the business and its products.